Fighting for our Friendships with Danielle Bayard Jackson

Episode 193 • November 22, 2026 • 00:48:38
Fighting for our Friendships with Danielle Bayard Jackson
Becoming Church
Fighting for our Friendships with Danielle Bayard Jackson

Nov 22 2026 | 00:48:38

/

Hosted By

Kristin Mockler Young

Show Notes

We all want friends - and we want to be a good friend - but even when two people connect, it doesn’t always work out. Sometimes it’s science or psychology, sometimes it’s life and sometimes it’s personalities that make friend types challenging. Layering faith onto it can make platonic, but deeply intimate, relationships even harder to navigate.

Danielle Bayard Jackson combines research about women’s cooperation and communication styles to help us see the covert strategies that women (in particular) use to hurt each other so we can do better. This episode will help you have hard conversations without losing the friendship, how to stop people-pleasing, how to recover the friendships worth saving and how to let go when you can’t.

Danielle’s research focuses mainly on women but this conversation will help everyone learn to make deeper connections with other people.

RELEVANT LINKS:

Grab “Fighting for our Friendships: The Science and Art of Conflict and Connection in Women’s Relationships” from Bookshop.org or the Becoming Church resource list on Amazon.

Follow @kristinmockleryoung and @mosaicclt on Instagram.

Leave a review on Apple Podcasts or Spotify

Order Kristin’s book “The Other Side of Certainty: How to Follow Jesus When Easy Answers No Longer Work” on Amazon or Bookshop.org or read Chapter One to see if it's right for you!

If you've already read "The Other Side of Certainty," leave a review on Amazon or Goodreads to help other people find it.

View Full Transcript

Episode Transcript

[00:00:10] Speaker A: We all want friends, and we want to be a good friend. But don't, you know, life doesn't always work out that way. Sometimes it's science, sometimes it's life, and sometimes it's personalities. So how do you navigate all that complexity in relationships? I'm Kristen Mochler Young, and this is Becoming Church, the podcast where we discuss how the message and movement of Jesus is not just about becoming Christians, but about becoming the church. Each week, we explore the intersection of faith, culture, and everyday life through the lens of Jesus. Today, I'm joined by Danielle Bayard Jackson, whose research and experience have led her to become a friendship expert, especially between females. Now, listen, this is still a conversation for everyone, because even if you yourself aren't a female with female friends, you. You are going to learn how the women in your life think and feel and process differently from you. And you just might pick up some tips along the way. Hey, Danielle. Welcome to the Becoming Church podcast. [00:01:07] Speaker B: I'm so glad to be here. Thank you for having me as a guest. [00:01:10] Speaker A: Oh, thrilled to have you. I was actually doing a little research on you before you hopped on, and I realized that you and I are both former classroom teachers who are now educating in a different way. [00:01:21] Speaker B: Shout out to teachers. When somebody tells me they're a former teacher, I'm like, oh, say less. I understand you. I know your life. Yeah, [00:01:27] Speaker A: but you did high school, right? [00:01:29] Speaker B: Yes. [00:01:30] Speaker A: Okay. I taught kindergarten, so we could not have been on more. Different. [00:01:32] Speaker B: Okay. Different ends of the spectrum. Yes. [00:01:37] Speaker A: Yes. Well, how did you come to be. Be the friendship expert after? Is it like what you watched girls not do, right, in the classroom? Like, how did this happen? [00:01:47] Speaker B: Yeah, no, I, I always joke that it certainly wasn't on my vision board when I was 10. Like, I'm gonna be a, you know, But I, you know, was a high school teacher. And the number one thing the girls wanted to talk about between classes and after school was their friendships. [00:02:01] Speaker A: And [00:02:01] Speaker B: I didn't realize at the time that I was kind of unofficially coaching them through those issues, but that's what I was doing. And so I often joke that I feel like I had a front row seat. And you may have seen this too, watching them re. Realize in real time, like, how do I get in with a new group? How do I repair if I made her mad? And now she's. She's not talking to me. So they're trying to. To figure that out, all those unspoken rules, especially for women during that time. And so I, you know, became the chair of the department and the other teachers in my department were like, we can't even get through good instruction time because the kids won't talk, and these girls don't have them in this group. And it was a whole thing. So when I left the classroom, I got into public relations. And I always joke that I made the foolish mistake of saying, oh, I'm no longer dealing with teenagers. I'm with mature, charismatic women. You know, but as, of course, you know, we have our issues too. And so when I realized that at every stage of womanhood, we're trying to figure out how do I connect with other women? I got curious. So since then, I've been leveraging my background in education to study what the latest research has to say about women's cooperation, communication, and conflict. [00:03:10] Speaker A: Okay. And we'll get into it more. We're going to dig a lot deeper into your book. But would you say, does it seem to be like, you know, you said there's different stages, right, obviously, of maturity and friendships. Do you kind of see the same patterns playing out from, like, childhood to adolescence to adulthood, but it just kind of, like, shifts a little bit? [00:03:29] Speaker B: Yeah. I always say the details look different, but I think the. The questions were perpetually asking are the same. And those questions are, who are my people? Where can I be myself? Where can I express the full extent of the love I have without shame or judgment? Those things have remained unchanged. But it is interesting to see how we kind of grow and change throughout the various life stages. [00:03:55] Speaker A: Yeah, I know. I'm one of those people that I feel like sometimes God is like, hey, I've talked to this lesson, but I'm gonna teach you again. Cause you didn't get it. So I'm wondering if it's that kind of right, friendship of like, okay, we. We learned how to forgive. We learned how to not talk about. Learned how to do all these things, but then we just have to keep learning and keep practicing. [00:04:13] Speaker B: Exactly that. I'm with you. [00:04:16] Speaker A: So you wrote a book called Fighting for Our Friendships. The Science and Art of Conflict and Connection in Women's Friendships. And I love that you. This came out of, like, adolescents, teens. Would you say this is a book that teenagers, like, teenage girls could read, or is it really more for adult women? [00:04:32] Speaker B: You know, I have struggled with that because I've definitely read the reviews on the book. And although they're mostly positive, you know, I. I have some women who are like, oh, I. I read this with my teenage daughter and was so helpful. So I'm like, okay, good. I. I love that it's accessible to them. But I definitely wrote it with adult women in mind. And some of the most common issues we experience as grown women trying to do all the things with former friendships that we're. We're learning from or still trying to recover from. [00:04:58] Speaker A: So [00:04:58] Speaker B: I wrote it with adult women in mind. But I have been glad to hear women say that it's been helpful to the young women in their lives as well. [00:05:07] Speaker A: Okay, good. Well, I have a. My oldest daughter is in middle school. She's in seventh grade, and she's, like, mature for her age when it comes to at least, like, relationships. So I'm gonna read it with her, and I will report back. I'll let you know. [00:05:18] Speaker B: Yes, please, [00:05:18] Speaker A: I will let you know. Well, Danielle, I want to know specifically because the show is called Becoming Church, and some of our women that are listening and guys that are listening are deep into, like, a small group, a Bible study. They're really connected into a church community. Others of them are not. Like, this might be their church for the week. This is their, you know, spiritual kind of like, digging in. And so I want to talk specifically for a second about friendships in the church because I feel like maybe there's a connection. And I'm curious what your perspective is between, like, the narrative that we're given as women in the church or even young girls to be agreeable and to be well liked, but maybe not to be honest or to show up authentically, and how that plays out specifically with, you know, Christian friendships. [00:06:05] Speaker B: Okay. I am so grateful for this conversation because I don't get to have it too often to be honest. And so to be in a space where I can kind of speak to the intersection of. Of my faith and church history. And also, you know, my. My, you know, background in the friendship world is really cool. Yes. Everything you just said, I've totally seen that. And I think it. It impacted me personally as well. And so if we believe that it's a virtue of not just womanhood, but Christian womanhood to be kind, cooperative, obedient, and pleasant, then it can feel incongruent to that. To go against the grain, to say, I'm not comfortable with that, to say, no, actually, I can't help with the post church yada, yada, because I gotta go do something else. I. It feels threatening to the. The virtue of an agreeable, kind, cooperative woman. And that can be difficult. [00:07:10] Speaker A: Do you think? I'm always hearing you say, like, the underlying issue or one of the underlying issues is that we're not taught to either trust ourselves or to use our voices or that we have value in having an opinion, like just as people first. And then of course, if we don't know how to do that in our lives, like how would we then transfer that to friendships? [00:07:30] Speaker B: Yeah, absolutely. I think, you know, we have conversations around like self worth and value and things like that. And I think that we might perhaps describe ourselves as maybe having high self esteem. And I think how we, where we really are is exposed during some of those moments, like setting boundaries with a friend or withdrawing from a friend group, which can feel so difficult and like such a risk if that group is rooted in church stuff. And so it's like, what are the other social impacts and ripple effects of me saying I don't want to be here anymore? This isn't good for me. This takes too much time. I don't like how I feel, you know, and me kind of counting the cost of withdrawing or is it going to be a whole thing? And so yeah, it's hard because being confident, preserving certain virtues and values that you have can be difficult. And it might be hard to like kind of toe that line. [00:08:28] Speaker A: Well, it's also so connected. I think relationships form our identity to begin with. But like you said, especially in faith, it's like, well, if I'm not part of this group or whatever, like, I don't know, do you feel like it's like a stronger hold maybe when it's connected to our faith? [00:08:45] Speaker B: You know, I would say so, but, and I, but I would say in general, I think anything where we're sharing certain values, worldviews. And so when I come to this place of friendship, I feel a sense of understanding, I feel a sense of ease. I feel seen and you just get it. And because I'm having that experience, I'm opening up about my life, you are praying for me, which is so intimate. It can be hard to extract yourself when these are the conditions of your friendship and it starts to kind of take over your life. Which friendships, to some degree they do that. They become the fabric of our everyday, especially if they're people who you are in physical close proximity with. So I'm seeing you all the time. Our kids are doing all the things together. You know, we're helping each other during certain challenges. You know, it can be hard to untether yourself. So. Yes. [00:09:37] Speaker A: Yeah. Well, you write about the research on women's relationships specifically being deeper but also more fragile and that we're more likely to abandon a relationship than maybe like guys or even, you know, A guy and a girl being relationship together. Why do you. Why? What have you found? Like, for the reason that that is. [00:09:55] Speaker B: Yeah, that kind of surprised me, too, when I first kind of got into studying this research. And the idea is that we integrate our women friends into our lives very deeply. So the research finds that we bring friends into our lives to the degree of a sibling, sibling, men to the degree of a cousin. And so because we're so close and we don't often compartmentalize, so it's like we kind of expect our friend will be all the things. I'm looking for her to be a friend. I can, you know, share resources with. With regarding to parenting, and we can pray together, and she can give me tips on finances. And, you know, she's my gym buddy. I kind of expect her to cover all the things. Whereas men tend to be a little more comfortable compartmentalizing. And it's okay if they have completely different views, but he's like my basketball buddy, you know, [00:10:39] Speaker A: and [00:10:40] Speaker B: so you. So on the other side of that is it kind of comes with more risk, because the closer you are to me, the better you can see my imperfections, the more trust there is. And so there's a higher chance of there being friction, which leads to separation. We also have research that finds that women tend to have higher expectations in their close relationships, both romantically and friendships. So if I expect more of you, and we're super close, there is a higher rate of friction. And so for men, you know, I know I'm generalizing, but we often make the joke that, you know, let's say a guy's getting married, and he's like, oh, I'm gonna make Tom my best man. And you're like, you haven't talked to Tom since the 11th grade. I don't understand. Who's Tom? You know, and so they. It's easy to keep someone at a distance and call them your best friend for 30 years. [00:11:30] Speaker A: It's [00:11:30] Speaker B: that risk and bringing them near. So we do have more former friendships than men do. They did a study with young girls where they asked them to list all the things their friends have done wrong. Were able to list more [00:11:43] Speaker A: than [00:11:43] Speaker B: a man's able to do, you know, so. So it is fragile, but more deep and more satisfying. Many say, [00:11:50] Speaker A: yeah, is it because I'm like, man, I have. I do. I feel that so hard. Like, the desire to have deep and intimate friendships, but also, like, the older I get, the more scared I get because I'm like. But I'm now also carrying Hurt of the past ones, you know, some of them being my fault, some of them being the fault of someone else. Some of them, like, who knows? And I would have not probably pre therapy thought about how there's also that connection to expectation. I have really high expectations for people, and I did when I was a teacher, and I do now as a pastor and as an employer, like, as, you know, an employee that has, you know, other people underneath me. And I just. Is it, like, biological that women just, like. I guess I'm trying to figure out, is this how we were raised again, back to that, or is it something like, scientifically, that's just how we are. [00:12:41] Speaker B: It's a lot of different things. But one of the things that I learned that was just interesting to me was there is work that kind of explores how women have traditionally been a part of. Oh, gosh, I don't want to get it wrong, but like patri. Local societies, and I might be saying it incorrect, but essentially they're saying that typically we move for the man. Like, he. We go. I mean, this is back in the day, but you know, how the man travels somewhere or his history or his background or lineage or whatever is somewhere. So we go wherever he goes. Okay, so when we think about what that looks like, that means that you sometimes have these villages or spaces that are made up of women who all came from somewhere else. And so if the men are going out and fighting or doing their thing, or we are depending on each other for our children's survival, these are the women I'm trusting with. You know, help me with my kids, because we're in the village together. So there's something about having to maintain cooperation together for survival. You know what I'm saying? I have to be in good standing with these women, and I have to have a good reputation because trust is important here. Cooperation is important here. We're sharing resource. And you have access to my most intimate and trusted resources, which [00:13:51] Speaker A: are [00:13:51] Speaker B: my children. And so when you think of it that way, and I know every woman's not like, literally a mother, but when we look at, like, some of the. The past wiring, right? And biologically, our leanings and tendencies. So because of that, some theorize that that might be why there are certain dynamics we have. We're like, we're upset with a woman, but you don't call it out directly. You maybe do little indirect, aggressive things or whatever it is, because we can't risk looking uncooperative. It costs too much for us socially. And then when I think about Women of color specifically, especially in certain friendship dynamics, like, what does it look like for me to push back and really thinking, should I just tolerate it and hush my mouth? Is it worth it? I'll tell you. There was one woman I worked with for a very long time. She was one of my longest running clients. And I'll call it a cooking club. I'll say she was a part of a cooking club at her church. And they met all the time. The way that she was stressed from this group with the gossip and the game playing of, like, who can join and who can't. But we met almost every month to talk about whether or not she should leave. And I'm trying to coach her through it because this has to be a decision she owns. She's seeing, like, man, this is. This has way more negatives than positives. But she kept thinking, but our husbands are friends. Does it make it awkward for them? And our kids are friend, and I'm going to see them on Sundays. And if I leave, like, does that mean I get kicked out of the group chat? Because then I also lose access to knowing what's going on. Like the resources, developments in the church, who's doing what. I don't want to. I don't want to lose that intel. So it just is so tricky sometimes how all these things are tethered together. And it's interesting to learn how much of this stuff might be biological or historical and how that all plays a role. [00:15:40] Speaker A: I mean, it definitely makes sense that trust and expectations are tied. It's like you said, of course, if I'm trusting that I can rely on you, then I'm going to have high expectations that, yes, you're going to do what you've told me you will do, that you've got my back, that the support is there, all the things. This takes me into the second part of your book, Danielle. You listed a whole bunch of different types of friends and how to understand kind of what's really going on. But I'm curious if first, like, part of the problem is that there's a difference between friendships and relationships and that maybe we don't. And maybe this goes back to expectations that, like, we don't know how to navigate. You know, when is it, are we just in a relationship with someone versus are we in an actual. Maybe it's like deeper, like friendship. Does that make sense? [00:16:23] Speaker B: It makes total sense. And I think what's so tricky about that is we all treat friendship differently. And so unlike romantic relationships where there's a pretty set Shared set of rules and terms. Like, for the most part, we're going to be monogamous. And then we go to certain levels and milestones. Like, we kind of know what that looks like. I mean, friendship is different from person to person. Some people like to declare it, some people don't. I mean, so many times we don't even know if we are friends. Like, I've had times where I'm like, oh, yeah, I just went to coffee with my friend. Well, this girl from my gym, you know, Like, I don't know yet. Like, friend feels a little maybe there, you know, so. And [00:16:58] Speaker A: then me, I'm like, oh, we're friends already. I'm like, oh, my friend. Yeah, we just chatted. [00:17:01] Speaker B: I'm like, well, she's my gym friends. Yeah, you know, there's. There's all these things of, like, how loosely we use the word, what it means, and what we believe that we owe each other. You know, I might feel like, well, she's. We're just kind of cool, but she's not a friend yet because that feels deeper. So I think even our not having, like a universal sequence and clear set of what it looks like to move toward friend can be tricky. I also think it's because unlike romantic relationships, we can have lots of different friends for different things. And so that can be kind of tricky as well. So. So yeah, calling someone a friend and identifying that you've gotten there can be tricky. But I do think that most people would agree that they have a certain set of expectations for their closer friends than for like, looser acquaintances. [00:17:48] Speaker A: Yeah, that definitely makes more sense that people see it differently. And also, back to, I think something you said earlier about how women kind of expect our friends to be everything. Like, I'm just thinking about, you know, as a. As a pastor, I'm. This is a common occurrence where there'll be like a small group or a Bible study, and then it's like, hey, this is our group. We get together, we talk about scripture, we do whatever. And then inevitably the groups get big enough, right. Where some of the women then go and hang out socially. And then the women that maybe just haven't connected. I genuinely believe it comes from a place like, not of mal intent, but it just. Certain connections. You connect with some people more than you connect with others. Again, different levels of friendship. But I ultimately always get the person that's like, they're leaving me out. What did I. What do I do? Can you intervene? And I'm like, I don't know if they're doing anything wrong. Like, I wasn't there. So I don't, you know. And now [00:18:43] Speaker B: that's interesting. Tell me more about an expectation of them or at least a request for you to help them facilitate what they perceive as, like, a malicious. [00:18:55] Speaker A: Well, and I think because it's connected to the church, right? It's like, well, you're the boss of the church, so I need you to help them, make sure that they see how they're leaving me out of the situation. And I never. I mean, I rarely, rarely do that. Like, that's like the last. I'm like, I will try to coach you. I'll try to help you. Here's. Have you advocated for yourself? Just like I would for my own daughters. You know, have the conversations. But it's just as interesting to me. And that's something that I've always kind of wrestled with of like, I don't think as long as they're not being intentionally cruel, as long as it's not, you know, a very, like, blatant exclusion. I understand how people could get their feelings hurt, but I wonder, I guess maybe my underlying question for you, Danielle, is like, how can I help those people to see they're not being left out? There's just a different level of connection that you have with some people sometimes. How do I help them? I guess, [00:19:48] Speaker B: yeah. Oh, my God. I have such strong feelings on this topic, and I [00:19:53] Speaker A: think it [00:19:54] Speaker B: rubs some people the wrong way, but it's just a reality check. Okay. And I also feel for you in your position where people are turning to you to kind of help them. And what they really need to change is like a mindset, like the. The way that they're perceiving, not being invited and. And dreaming up the scenario that the women are getting together to intentionally and conspiratorially decide to not leave somebody out as opposed to. They're just really connected. Maybe it's because they're both in a. A certain season in their marriage and they just feel understood or with motherhood or honestly. And I'm the same sense of humor. And there's a certain flow and there's research that finds that shared humor for women, not men, but shared humor for women is a predictor of best friendship. And I like going back to that because it seems so simple or maybe like, not relevant or. But it's just like. I mean, if two women experience a certain ease, then you might find them drawing nearer to each other more often. If they are sharing a certain interest or season, they might want to Be together. And the objective of the gathering was for these two people to bond and connect and to have a conversation about a certain thing. Here's another one I'm gonna throw at you that's not popular, but I'm telling you, it's so real is sometimes it's even conversation styles. If you have somebody who's an interrupter or they draw it back to themselves. Nothing wrong with that. But you might find for others that it is a disruptive pattern and they want a certain social. I mean, it just is what it is. Or at the end of the day, they weren't even thinking about you. [00:21:34] Speaker A: And [00:21:34] Speaker B: so I know that might be hard to swallow, but it's really hard, I think. And I see it on social media all the time where when we were not invited to something, immediately we vilify the people who went. And that's just not fair. [00:21:47] Speaker A: Yeah. Do you think it's just a projection of, like, past hurts? Because we've all done that, [00:21:51] Speaker B: Right? [00:21:51] Speaker A: Sure. [00:21:53] Speaker B: And it doesn't help to be able to see every gathering ever. [00:21:56] Speaker A: Right. [00:21:56] Speaker B: People's Instagram stories. Right. [00:21:58] Speaker A: Right. When it comes to faith friendships especially, I know. This conversation becomes even more layered. That's why I wrote an entire chapter in my book, the Other side of Certainty on friendships. I cover how legalism and self righteousness have led to us showing up without grace, how we can forgive ourselves and move on from the guilt and shame we feel or carry, even from friendships of past versions of ourselves. And I write about how to move forward in healthy relationships that risk hurt because they're founded in a truer love. There's a link in the show notes. Or you can find the Other side of Certainty wherever books are sold. It would make a great gift for that friend who's the glue of your friend group, or your mahjong host or your small group leader, Any of the people who often bear the responsibility of helping to manage other people's relationships. I wonder, Danielle, too, like, how this made me think, like, how often do you think we fool ourselves just again, thinking about all these different types of friends, where we think we are one type of friend, when in reality the problem might be that we are not actually showing up like we think we are. [00:23:07] Speaker B: Yeah, [00:23:09] Speaker A: it's me. Hi. [00:23:10] Speaker B: Yeah, [00:23:11] Speaker A: I'm the problem. It's me. [00:23:13] Speaker B: It's so hard because there's a lot more gray area than I think we give to friendship. And I think a lot of that might be due to us packaging it as, like, a. Oh, friendship should just be, like, natural and organic, and it's just not true. There's a lot of conversation that needs to be had. We need clarification because we assume, well, if it's meant to be as friends, like, it'll just be like, so natural. And I don't think it's fair to hold this relationship to that standard. But we don't do it anywhere else. In your romantic relationship. There is totally an expectation that will check in and be like, babe, I'm just not feeling connected this week. What's going on? [00:23:51] Speaker A: What [00:23:51] Speaker B: are we. What are we doing right? In your job, there's dedicated time for a performance review. How's this going? What do I need to do to grow? What do you need from me? There's something about friendship where we don't break the fourth wall. You don't, you [00:24:04] Speaker A: don't [00:24:04] Speaker B: talk about the dynamic. Just do it. And I think it leads to a lot of hurt and confusion about what we are, what we want, what our goals are. And that can be really, really difficult. So when it comes to being a certain kind of friend, first, I'll say when it comes to reciprocity, women really value something called mutual prioritization. So it's important to us to feel like if you're my number one or my number two, I'm assuming I'm your number one, your number two. So it's harder for us to. For some women to still be in friendship. If you feel like she's your number two, but you're her number five, you know, and I'm [00:24:36] Speaker A: saying [00:24:36] Speaker B: these numbers arbitrarily, that can be difficult. And when it comes to showing up as a friend, I think we have to do a lot of honest self reflection about, like, lord, help me see where I can be more like you. And I really do believe that that translates in our relationships. And I don't mean to, like, be reductive or oversimplify, but, like, help to give me the strength and humility to receive feedback from other people and to be brave enough to remove myself from situations that. That feel really hard without worrying about how I'll be perceived. So there's a lot of gray area, but I think we have to be able to have very distinct and technical conversations the same way we would anywhere else. [00:25:19] Speaker A: I mean, there's a humility and a self awareness that comes with anything. Right? I think it's very. I think it's very wise for you to suggest for people to be like, all right, God, show me where I am. The problem. Show me where. Because my guess is it's not like, oh, I. I'm gonna have this issue only with, like. Only with Danielle. Like, that's the only place I probably. Whatever. If it's pride, if it's jealousy, if it's cynicism, if it's projecting past hurts on people, it's probably happening across the board. [00:25:47] Speaker B: Yes. And [00:25:48] Speaker A: it would be. Probably been [00:25:49] Speaker B: told multiple times by multiple people. Your mother and your cousin have all said it. There's something there. Yeah, [00:25:54] Speaker A: yeah, yeah. I'm wondering, too, if women use intimacy as, like, a form of conflict avoidance. And what I mean is, at least in my own experience, I will, like, fight with somebody, a girlfriend, especially about something that's, like, superficial, when really I'm upset about something deeper, but I have a hard time talking about the actual issue. [00:26:19] Speaker B: Interesting. Yeah. I wonder if that goes back to our, like, internal obligation that we feel to, like, maintain cooperation. So maybe the idea of bringing up the big thing or bringing up the real root of the thing feels very risky for a couple reasons. One, I think it's because for a lot of people, friendship is supposed to be this easy, recreational thing. So am I killing the vibe by making it serious and telling you how you hurt me then? Friendship is an elective relationship. So I don't want to do anything to push you away and to tempt you to opt out. And so I want to kind of be. I'm cool, I'm chill, you know, which I think is the third thing. I want to be perceived as being, like, chill and easy. I'm not difficult. And will me telling you, hey, what you said last night at dinner, you know, kind of rub me the wrong way. What did you mean by that? That feels scary to say. So I'm just going to be chill and really make it about something else very quickly. Well, I have something that I designed, a framework called the three affinities. And I think a lot of conflicts can be traced back to that, too. [00:27:24] Speaker A: Yeah. Do you want to break that down for us? [00:27:25] Speaker B: Yeah, very quickly. I just would argue that with all the research that I have seen, it always comes back to three things. Three things that make us feel really close to one another. And I believe that if these things are absent or perceived as being unequal, that becomes the root of all your issues. The first one is symmetry. We really like feeling like there's reciprocity and egalitarianism. We are equals. This is why it feels really jarring when you feel like a friend is kind of being judgy, because the implication there is that her choices are superior than yours or that she's. We suspect she's jealous because does that display desire to, you know, be beyond you or supersede you? You know, so. So that or her efforts aren't the same as mine. We're supposed to be equals and all the same, you know, so symmetry feels really important to us. Then there is a secrecy. And this doesn't necessarily mean literal secrets, but the feeling of, like, being in this mutually exclusive vault. And in the vault we share. I share, you share, I share, you share. That is the glue of women's relationships. [00:28:34] Speaker A: Yeah. [00:28:34] Speaker B: This is why it feels like a violation if she shares outside the vault something you shared or if you feel like you're sharing and she's not. What. What's that about? I feel foolish. I feel naked. You know, like you. You say something too. And this is also why if she tells another friend before you about the health scare or. Or the job loss, she's entitled to tell somebody else before you. But you still feel that pinch because it's like, what the heck, you know? So that's important to us. And finally, support, which seems very simple, but the research finds that the number one thing women look for in their same sex friendships is emotional support. Meaning if I don't get this, then we have an issue because this is the bare minimum. So if you're feeling like, oh, that's what it is. Our support is not even our. We're not similar. I feel like we're not sharing in the vault. It can often, I believe, be traced to one of those three things, which I think is helpful to give us some direction into knowing how to recalibrate, because it doesn't necessarily mean friendship's over. It might mean, like, oh, okay, I think I have language for what's happening. How do I invite her into a conversation to kind of like, restore that? [00:29:44] Speaker A: Yeah. Danielle, how would you encourage women who feel like, okay, there, there is a. There's a rift, or my feelings are hurt, or she doesn't understand, while there is that fear, right, of either losing their belonging or their person. You know, like, again, that very deep emotional tie. How would you encourage them to say the thing is? Or unless it's just say the thing. [00:30:09] Speaker B: Yeah, two things. The first is, I like to go from the research first so that, you know, it's not just in your head. But the research finds that people report feeling closer to one another on the other side of healthy conflict. So I want you to think about in a romantic partnership, like when you guys kind of went back and forth. But then afterwards, you felt, like, almost stronger as a unit that you went through it, and you also walk away like, wow, he, like, cares about how I feel. Like it mattered to him to hear that that hurt me. It's the same thing. So knowing intellectually. Okay, wait a second. We could have the platonic intimacy I claim to want if I tell her that this persistent habit makes me uncomfortable. Yes. [00:30:48] Speaker A: Yeah. [00:30:49] Speaker B: And there's a chance that she does not take it well, which is also very important data, because do I want to be friends where we can have fun? But if I tell you that there's a certain thing that's making me uncomfortable, that's the limitation. We can't go there. Is that something I'm willing to endure? You have to ask yourself that. So when it comes to bringing it up, I think that one thing that can be helpful is to do it alongside reassurances and an objective. So I like letting them know up front. I like starting with vulnerability. So I often tell women, as an exercise, I want you to think about the main reason you. You don't want to have this conversation and make that your opening sentence. So perhaps I might say, hey, you know, I've been wanting to talk to you about something, but the last thing I want is for it to be awkward in the friend group. [00:31:35] Speaker A: The [00:31:35] Speaker B: last thing I want is for, like, you to be upset with me. But. But it's just important to me that I share it anyway, you know, so I'm letting you know I'm. I've been thoughtful about this. I have fears around this, but I'm going for it because this is worth it to me. [00:31:51] Speaker A: Right? You are worth it to [00:31:52] Speaker B: 100% [00:31:53] Speaker A: my life. Yeah. Yeah. [00:31:54] Speaker B: Because if I wasn't bringing it up, it's because I'm like, you know, I'm tapping out anyway, so it's not worth raising this in service of the friendship. And hopefully I keep stressing the right people because the right people can understand that. I think reasonable women who also value the friendship, you are safe to do that with them. Then not everybody but you, you know, with most reasonable people who value the friendship. And then whenever the issue is you want to present it just like, as hard data I have found works better. So I think any language that feels accusatory or vague, I have always seen that go left. So that means I'm not saying things like, I just kind of feel like you've had a, you know, bit of an attitude or you've kind of been standoffish. Now we've opened it to debate. When was that an attitude? How did I not [00:32:41] Speaker A: feel like a broad attack as opposed to 100. My [00:32:45] Speaker B: character? Yeah. So instead it's like a, hey, we're doing facts. Hey, I noticed the last, you know, couple times that we met up, you weren't as talkative as before. Or I noticed the last couple of hangouts that we have, you know. You know, you made some jobs about or some jokes about my, you know, new boyfriend, you know, And I'm just trying to understand, like, what you meant by that because it feels a little hurtful. Right. You know, so I'm telling you factually, these things have changed or these things have happened. And here's the impact. Because people can't really contest that. If I'm telling you, you said this thing and it embarrassed me, there ain't much to talk about. [00:33:18] Speaker A: Right. [00:33:18] Speaker B: You could tell me what you meant. You could tell me, oh, my gosh, I'm so sorry. I didn't mean it like that. But you cannot take away from me saying, hey, that made me feel a little embarrassed or maybe kind of. Kind of angry a little bit. You can't take away from that. So I'm inviting them in. It's not an accusation. It's an invitation. Here was the impact. Help me understand. And I'll be honest. I'm not just going to share from a place of. I've had to deliver this. I've had it delivered to me. And some things that have helped to me are women saying things. Like, a couple years ago, a friend addressed something with me about something I did that hurt her. That I don't think was a messed up thing to do, but it hurt her. So I'm still listening. And she kept saying things like, you know, you know, the story I'm telling myself is you went with that friend because you're closer to her, and you just, like, aren't as invested in this friendship, which is like, oh, my God, you know? But she was using language like, the story I'm telling, telling myself, is this. Is that true? Or when you made that choice, it made me think this. Like, help me out. Can you help me understand? And it was not accusatory. She. I could tell she was inviting me in because she cared that my side of things mattered to her. And it just completely changed the tone of the conversation. And so I've really done a lot of practicing, you know, since those conversations. I've learned from my friends. [00:34:35] Speaker A: Yeah, I just. I just keep hearing, like, maturity, ladies, it takes a little bit of maturity. Like, I. I'm gonna just go ahead and tell you, even though maybe I shouldn't have to, I'm gonna do it anyway. Stop having these conversations through text message. Like, if this is a. A friendship that matters, if this is a relationship that matters, don't hide behind your phone because you think it's gonna be easier, it's gonna make it worse. Like, we can read into so much tone and whatever. Like, if you. If you care about this person, meet them for coffee. [00:35:06] Speaker B: Oh, my God. Yes. Yes. And amen. There's this book called Digital Body Language. I talk about it all the time, and at this point, I want commissions for how many times I've talked about this book, but it's called Digital Body Language. And it's so good because the author, Erica Dewan, is making a case for how there are all these things that shape how they receive your message. Who cares how you intended it? So she says things like the brevity or length of your message. Right. If I text really long, do I look like I'm unhinged? Do I. I'm being. I mean, or do I look like I'm super serious? So long. Yeah. Or. Or. Or thoughtful, you know, and then if it's really short, do I look hurt? Like, I don't care? Like, I didn't have time for this. Even though you were just kind of being to the point, but you leave the room for that interpretation. Emojis, I'm trying to convey, like, I'm just kind of being playful and it's cool, but to them, does it look like I'm not taking it seriously? [00:36:03] Speaker A: Right? Like, [00:36:04] Speaker B: if you're putting emojis, you're not being serious right now. [00:36:06] Speaker A: Yeah. [00:36:06] Speaker B: You know, don't [00:36:07] Speaker A: you dare put a thumbs up for a millennial. We know that's passive aggressive. Don't do it. [00:36:10] Speaker B: You're done. You're done. Okay? You're done. 100%. And it's the meaning that we assign. And then here's another big one that I've gotten in trouble for is the duration between messages. [00:36:22] Speaker A: Right. If [00:36:23] Speaker B: I send you something about how you hurt me, or I'm asking a question about being left out, and you don't respond for two days now I'm like, wow, Like, I'm an afterthought, you don't even care. Or there's room for me to think, is this a power play that you're not getting back to me? But if you're also responding very, very quickly and sending lots of messages, do you look Upset, [00:36:43] Speaker A: Never really thought through and heard me. Yeah, [00:36:45] Speaker B: a hundred percent. So to your point, there's something about being in person where you can see me taking a breath or I can touch your arm gently while I say like girl, that kind of hurt my feelings. But it's coupled with, you know, a hand on the wrist to show you, like I'm trying to be warm, you know, so. So it's so deeply uncomfortable and scary, but I think it would just save us so much misunderstanding. [00:37:08] Speaker A: Yeah. Danielle, I want to ask about. Because we. That's so that's kind of like repair, right? Hopefully that goes in best case scenario, friendships can be repaired or whatever relationship, whatever number, whatever level. But sometimes, and I know probably every single person listening has experienced this where the friendship doesn't last, where because we're willing to fight for it, but the other person can't or isn't willing to or for whatever reason, they. They just can't. And sometimes that's because of a rift, sometimes it's because of a move, a change of, you know, season of life, like, so be it, but it's still really painful. And so I'm curious what encouragement you have for the women who are trying to move on, I guess from a relationship that the other person has clearly just kind of said. Said or not said explicitly, but by their actions, you know, I'm over, I'm over it. How can they kind of move on when this recurring sense of grief still pops up? [00:38:04] Speaker B: First, let me say, don't you dare feel any shame or embarrassment about being deeply hurt by something that's quote, just a friendship. I hear [00:38:12] Speaker A: that all [00:38:12] Speaker B: the time. [00:38:13] Speaker A: Said that [00:38:13] Speaker B: like, I mean, yeah, yes, it was a friendship and that really matters. And you heard me speak earlier to like how deeply we integrated into our lives. So naturally, you know, having that extracted from your life would be really painful. And you know, it's also something where, you know, you have research finding that friendships are a part of our self concept. So a part of how I see myself is through the lens of how my friends see me. And I know we can be like, well, you shouldn't care how. No, the fact that my friends think I'm interesting and smart and funny and cool makes me think I am because these girls think so, you know, and so the opposite of that sometimes happens when it's over. Well, am I not as lovable or interesting if they unchose me? And so a part of me is even kind of questioning who I am that this woman I love and respect and have history with no longer wants me around. That can have you questioning your value. So that is so much to wrestle with. Like, psychologically, emotionally, that's so much to wrestle with. And on top of that, it can be difficult to move forward when you have the lack of closure. If you are part of a friendship breakup where it was not explicitly said, but you know, you're not crazy, the calls aren't coming anymore, the texts aren't coming anymore. You've mustered the courage to ask, hey, are we good? And she looked you in your face and said, oh, my God, of course we're fine. And you know, you know things are different. It can be harder to move on without closure or understanding of. Of what's happening because your brain's searching for answers and is not at rest. So of course you'd be like, what the heck? At some point, you would have to get to a point where if you feel comfortable and it's appropriate to ask and they've chosen to give you an answer, even if it's dishonest, so they're giving you corrupted data. Even if you, you. You don't understand it or you haven't really gotten much, at some point you would have to say, I don't know why things aren't like they used to be. And gosh darn out, it makes me sad. But I have to accept that I might never know. I am grateful for what the friendship offered during the time we were together. And I am. I don't believe that my friendship heartbreak is unworthy of taking to God that it. That it's small or silly. Lord, my heart hurts. Lord, I miss my friends. Lord, I'm sad. And I'm asking you to position me to invite new friendships into my life. I'm asking you to open my eyes to whatever I need to learn. What are you trying to show me through this separation? And I ask that you bless her. And that is hard. [00:41:02] Speaker A: And [00:41:02] Speaker B: I'll end with this. There's one time I offered an exercise to some women, and one of them was to identify one thing you're grateful for from the friendship. Because the research says if you're able to do that, you're more likely to move forward without bitterness and resentment. And so we're like, what's, what's one thing? I mean, even if we're scraping the bottom of the bag, and we're like, well, she did have a great taste in music, and [00:41:24] Speaker A: I [00:41:24] Speaker B: got so many good. I mean, if you're scraping the bottom of the barrel, okay, but identify one thing you're grateful for. And a young woman started crying, and I was like, what's coming up for you? And she was like, I feel like I can't do that because I don't want to give her any power. [00:41:39] Speaker A: And [00:41:40] Speaker B: there was some heart stuff going on. Like, I can't even say what I'm grateful for. She was awful, you know, and I understand that. But until we're able to say, I might never know why she unchose me, but God bless her. And Lord, won't you restore some things that feel broken in me. And Lord, won't you use it. Won't you use this to. To position me for friendships that bring me closer to you and help me to. To. To grow and to. To feel love and to. To express my love. I mean, that's kind of where we got to find a way to get to. From a practical sense, doing things like not following her on social media. I. I cannot stress that enough. Do you think you saying I got to move forward, but let me check her Instagram stories. Stop stalking her. I mean, gosh, stop doing it to your brain. You're saying, I want to move on, but let me keep checking in. No, I'm not following her on socials. I'm not asking about her in certain groups, like, to get the intel, like, do you know what happens? And I haven't heard from her. I'm not repeating the story multiple times when. Well, meaning mutual friends say, well, what happened with you and Janet? I'm not going through. I'm practicing my PR response. Girl, if I'm being honest with you, I still don't know. But I'll tell you one thing. You know, we had a good time while we were friends, and I think we're just kind of in different places, period. [00:43:01] Speaker A: Yep. Done. [00:43:02] Speaker B: Retelling that story certainly isn't helping either. And then I would say if this was a person who was very integrated into your social life, like you guys had Friday nights together and Saturdays, maybe it might be time to pursue goals that you feel like you couldn't while you were together [00:43:15] Speaker A: to [00:43:15] Speaker B: try some new hobbies. And if you love yoga or whatever it is, I'm going to a new yoga spot or at a new day. So you might need to switch up the schedule because sometimes when you maintain the same schedule, it only highlights her absence in your life. So shaking it up a little bit can be helpful in your. Your journey toward moving on. [00:43:36] Speaker A: So many good practicals. I. I thank you just for holding that. That tender spot for me. Gratitude was. And because the grief. There's a couple. The grief still pops up, and it makes me so sad. But learning to remember that, like, gratitude piece is what helps me to move on and go, okay, I'm still sad about this. And this still hurts because I loved her so much, and her. Her presence in my life meant so much. I have two more questions for you. Really quick. Danielle, I want to know what can our friendships teach us about God, about our faith? [00:44:04] Speaker B: Oh, gosh, a couple things. I'll make this one personal. I think for me, it's taught me a lot about forgiveness [00:44:14] Speaker A: and [00:44:14] Speaker B: not because I have to forgive my friends, because they have forgiven me. [00:44:18] Speaker A: Yeah. [00:44:19] Speaker B: And it's so interesting to see, like, our bits or shadows of our relationship with the Lord and how it plays out with other human beings. So that's been one. And then also just how much he loves me because he does use people to. To love on you. That's why I've never really been thrilled with any messages around, like, I don't need anybody. I just need God and I need my family. Like, but you do, though. And he has given us the gift of people to send a word, to send a hug, to bring a meal. You know, that. That is him orchestrating things so that I can feel loved on a certain way. And so it shows how much. Much he. He loves me, I think, through friendship. And that's been. That's been a really cool experience. [00:45:08] Speaker A: Yeah, I love that. I have a last question for you because the podcast is called Becoming Church. How can the people listening become the church to the people around them, maybe specifically in their friendships? [00:45:20] Speaker B: Oh, I love this question. You probably see this a lot on social media, but I would. I would say taking inventory of the times you are feeling inconvenienced and so you don't opt in. And being the church means a lot of things, but it means showing up, doing the work, fellowship, studying scripture together, all the things. And it's not convenient. There are so many elements of living that, as a practice that are not convenient or comfortable, that work against my interests, my schedule, my goals, my personality. But we're called to be the church in whatever way that looks like. So I would say, look at the times you said no to connection opportunities or requests for help because you were not in the mood. You had other plans. It wasn't your, quote, vibe. I would say, look, over the past month, how many times did you say no to requests for help, support, connection, attending an event that somebody who cares about you really wanted you to show up at their thing and you were like, ah, I would tell you to look at that, take account and see what you come up with. But I think that that can be very telling. [00:46:42] Speaker A: Okay. What a great suggestion. You've given us so much homework. I love it. Janelle, this has been so wonderful, so beautiful. Thank you so much. We will link up your book, your website, all of the things that people can find you and follow you and continue to learn from your expertise. [00:46:58] Speaker B: Oh, I so appreciate you. Hey, I. I think it's really cool that you have facilitated a moment to have this conversation because friendship conversation can feel kind of pie in the sky and cute and community. But thank you for making space to talk about the nuance of it, the messy, uncomfortable parts of it, because I think it's important, especially when we talk about friendship in the church. So I was. I'm thrilled to be able to have this conversation at this particular intersection. And I'm so grateful to be a guest. [00:47:27] Speaker A: We're leading the way. We're leading the way. Okay, friends. See, because I am that person that loves hard and fast and considers you all to be my friends unless you tell me otherwise. I'm so grateful for you being here. I encourage you to pick one thing that Danielle suggested, whether that's taking an inventory of your nose, praying for wisdom and courage to be honest with your hurts, or doing the hard work work of sitting in humility to see where you may be displaying some unhealthy patterns in your friendships. I'm praying your maturity will be rewarded with a deeper sense of closeness and connection on the other side of it. I'd love for you to send this episode to a friend again. To your small group or your Bible study leader, to your book club or your mahjong group, or to any group chat where there's a communal dynamic. You just never know how it's going to help someone that you love to feel seen and supported just by copying and pasting a link. Thank you for sharing. Until next time. Thanks so much for listening and keep becoming the church to the people around you.

Other Episodes

Episode 88

November 17, 2024 • 00:51:47
Episode Cover

Pricelis Perreaux-Dominguez: Being a Sanctuary

Is the church in crisis? If that thought makes you sad or angry, you can change the narrative around the American Church. Pricelis Perreaux-Dominguez...

Listen

Episode 169

June 07, 2026 • 00:57:46
Episode Cover

Rethinking Mission Trips with Mekdes Haddis

Thinking about mission trips might excite you or it might make you nervous that God will call you to sacrifice more than you have...

Listen

Episode 1

January 23, 2022 • 00:12:45
Episode Cover

Trailer: Why Becoming Church?

In this initial episode, Kristin interviews Naeem Fazal, lead pastor of Mosaic Church, about what to expect from this podcast and why we think...

Listen