Who Are You Becoming? with Chuck DeGroat

Episode 192 • November 15, 2026 • 00:54:22
Who Are You Becoming? with Chuck DeGroat
Becoming Church
Who Are You Becoming? with Chuck DeGroat

Nov 15 2026 | 00:54:22

/

Hosted By

Kristin Mockler Young

Show Notes

Narcissism in the church is not new, but it is on the rise in leadership and the systems that perpetuate misguided discipleship. Professor and spiritual director Chuck DeGroat believes we can mature past quick comebacks, empty apologies and shallow character to truly change and become the best versions of ourselves.

This conversation asks hard questions about pastors who get re-platformed, and the victims who still suffer harm post-apology. It will also explain why some American Evangelicals seem to pledge an allegiance to leaders who leverage faith language while looking nothing like Jesus. I pray this episode helps you find spiritual healing and a more regulated nervous system as you move toward wholeness in Christ.

RELEVANT LINKS:

Grab “Who You’re Becoming: The Slow and Courageous Work of Cultivating Character in a Narcissistic Age” from Bookshop.org or the Becoming Church resource list on Amazon.

Follow @kristinmockleryoung and @mosaicclt on Instagram.

Leave a review on Apple Podcasts or Spotify

Order Kristin’s book “The Other Side of Certainty: How to Follow Jesus When Easy Answers No Longer Work” on Amazon or Bookshop.org or read Chapter One to see if it's right for you!

If you've already read "The Other Side of Certainty," leave a review on Amazon or Goodreads to help other people find it.

View Full Transcript

Episode Transcript

[00:00:00] Speaker A: Foreign. Scroll your social media feed for just a minute and it probably won't take too long for you to see headlines of pastors being re platformed after short sabbatical stints and books and podcasts being produced about what they've learned from their mistakes. But what about the people who experienced harm? Where is the healing for the victim? This conversation will cover both sides of restoration. I'm Kristin Mockler Young and this is Becoming Church, the podcast where we discuss how the message and movement of Jesus is not just about becoming Christians, but about becoming the church. Each week we explore the intersection of faith, culture and everyday life through the lens of Jesus. I'm asking hard questions today because Chuck DeGrow is an expert who can handle them with decades of experience and research. He's here to talk about narcissism and how it shows up not only in leaders, but in church systems and even the collective psyche of American Christianity as a whole. It's a fascinating conversation and I encourage you to think of at least one person you can share it with as you're listening. Hey, Chuck DeGroat, welcome to the Becoming Church podcast. [00:01:16] Speaker B: Great. Thank you, Kristen. [00:01:18] Speaker A: I'm so happy to have you. You've got a couple different books. We're going to talk about your latest one today, but why don't you just give people a little bit of, you know, whatever you find to be important information about who you are? [00:01:31] Speaker B: Yeah. Wow. So I've been teaching at Western Theological Seminary for the last 13 years. I was a pastor in San Francisco and Orlando, Florida before that where I started two church based counseling centers. And I've started a clinical counselor training program here at the seminary. And so I get to be invested in the leadership of development formation of pastors and counselors here at the seminary. Sarah and I are empty nesters now. I've got two daughters who are married. My oldest daughter and son in law are in our counseling program here, which is kind of fun. [00:02:07] Speaker A: Oh, cool. But you're not counseling them, Shirley. [00:02:10] Speaker B: No, no, they're training. They're training. In fact, my [00:02:13] Speaker A: daughter, [00:02:14] Speaker B: my daughter is in her clinical internship right now and she's killing it. I'm so proud of her. [00:02:19] Speaker A: So [00:02:20] Speaker B: it's a bit of a family affair. I've got seven books out. This is the latest one, who you're becoming and yeah, just really grateful for that journey too and how I've gotten to do a little bit of writing over the years as well. [00:02:33] Speaker A: That's awesome. Chuck, as you, you were a pastor and now you are helping to Develop pastors. [00:02:39] Speaker B: That's right. [00:02:40] Speaker A: What do you miss about pastoring, and what do you actually like that you're doing better now? [00:02:45] Speaker B: That's a great question. Well, I don't miss a whole lot about pastoring. Ask any pastor and they'll tell you that it can be really wearying. And I've got some stories along the way. I love being involved in the formation of pastors and therapists. I'm also a licensed therapist, and I do that kind of work, too. And so I've been able to straddle those worlds over the years. But to be involved in forming the character, the health, the rhythms of pastors and therapists feels really important to me in this season of life and to be on that kind of ground level. And we've got students ranging from like 22 to 72 here, so we've got the whole range, and it's really great. [00:03:31] Speaker A: That's really encouraging to hear that it's not just like the new up and coming ministry leaders, but people that have been in it for decades. Hey, I think I could actually use a little help. [00:03:41] Speaker B: Yeah, that's right. Yeah, that's right. And we've got a lot of pastors and leaders who are in it, doing doctoral programs here. I lead that program, too. And most of them do it not for the degree, but because they're lonely and they need care, they need formation. And so we're just seeing that. That there are a lot of people doing really good work and they need community and care in the midst of that. [00:04:03] Speaker A: Yeah. Well, thank you for. For providing that. I've been in ministry for eight years, I think, and it is. That is one of the surprising things was it is lonely in a way. You're, like, always surrounded by people, people that. [00:04:15] Speaker B: Yes. [00:04:15] Speaker A: That love you, people that you love. But it's not the same as, you know, being able to talk to somebody who understands or who gets it. So I know it's a very needed service that you're providing. [00:04:26] Speaker B: Yes. [00:04:27] Speaker A: Well, Chuck, as a. As a therapist, pastor, spiritual director, I know you've done a lot of research in narcissism. [00:04:33] Speaker B: Yeah. [00:04:34] Speaker A: And we're going to dig into it. But I think for the people that are listening, you know, we think of those big indicators of narcissism. Right. Like the big red flags. But what are some things that people might not recognize as signs of narcissism? [00:04:46] Speaker B: Oh, that's such a good question, because you're exactly right. We, we look for the indicators. We look for the narcissistic personality. Which we assume will be the kinds of things that we read about in the dsm, which is kind of the, the bible of psychology. Right. Grandiosity, attention seeking, things like that. What people might not know is that the underlying dynamic of narcissism is a psyche, a body, a nervous system organized around defense. And so this is a person who learned a long time ago that the world isn't safe. And it's like, it's a dog eat dog world and it's like eat or be eaten. Right. And so not that they decided that at 6 years old or 8 years old or 10 years old, but subconsciously, unconsciously, this is what emerged and developed. And so because that's the case, there is this sort of unconscious reactivity in the world when, when a narcissist is in fight mode. Again, it's not like you woke up that morning and said, I'm going to go into fight mode, although there can be intentionality for sure. It's that this is the only dynamic his body knows. And so a lot of the work that I've done with those on the narcissistic spectrum over the years is not so much about, sure, we want to identify the grandiosity and the attention seeking, the personality, the characteristics, but we want to deal with that early organization, the wounds that led to this way of relating and really harming and, and really reckon with that. [00:06:26] Speaker A: Yeah. Chuck, when you said it's like a defense, is there, is it rooted really like in insecurity? [00:06:33] Speaker B: Yeah. Well, I think you're onto something there. Because what we often say is the underside of narcissism is shame. Right. And so there [00:06:41] Speaker A: is [00:06:42] Speaker B: that basic shame, that basic insecurity that's there that you wouldn't exactly notice at first. Right. Because they appear so confident. [00:06:50] Speaker A: Yeah. [00:06:51] Speaker B: And yet I've done enough of this work over really 25 plus years now that, you know, behind the scenes on that couch over there [00:06:59] Speaker A: in [00:06:59] Speaker B: my office, I'll sit with a man, a pastor, who, you know, in the safety of this particular space and a relationship, I hope, where he can feel like he's known, where there's empathy, but there's also accountability for harm that he, he can begin to say, actually I live with such terror, such fear, such shame. And when, when we're able to get there, that's when we begin to see change. Now I'm not here to say that that happens a lot. It actually happens pretty rarely that, that we get there to that place where there's, you know, the, the beginnings of real change. And, [00:07:40] Speaker A: and [00:07:40] Speaker B: where we can see transformation all the way through. But when we get there, it's beautiful. [00:07:45] Speaker A: Okay, Chuck, I'm going to ask you a question because you have said, and I know we're just in conversation, right. Words come out, but you've said him multiple times. And I do know that pastors are, Listen, I'm a female pastor. I get it. It is a, it is a male dominated field. [00:08:01] Speaker B: Yeah. [00:08:01] Speaker A: But is this also something that you see more in men than women? [00:08:05] Speaker B: Yeah, yeah. Well, I, I teach it in egalitarian seminary and I'm fully egalitarian myself. And you know, so I'm in these spaces where I'm, I'm working with men and women in pastoral ministry. But the short answer is yes. And they're. There are reasons why. And those numbers could change, those stats could change. Let's just say the stats flip and many, many more women ascend into roles of senior pastoral leadership and institutional leadership over the next 50 years. [00:08:41] Speaker A: Well, [00:08:41] Speaker B: let's then look at the statistics. But I think by and large, over the course of my, know, my season of, of ministry and therapeutic work and consultancy and things like that, it's an inordinate number of men. And when we see women on the narcissistic spectrum, it shows up a little bit differently. It might not show up as the grandiosity that you see in the kind of dominant leader on stage, Am I. Previous book, When Narcissism Comes to Church, I went into the nine faces of Narcissism and that's where you can see a little bit of, you know, the other kinds of dynamics. So. Yeah, [00:09:27] Speaker A: yeah, thank you. I'm glad you brought that up because when you wrote that book, I think it came out in 2020, you also talked about how obviously the different nine types of narcissism in leaders, but you also talked about narcissism in church systems. [00:09:41] Speaker B: Yeah. [00:09:42] Speaker A: What does that look like? Because of course I think this. Right. It's like, it's a personality trait. So I'm like, how does a system. [00:09:46] Speaker B: Yeah, right. And churches and systems have personalities too, in a sense, right? [00:09:52] Speaker A: Yeah. [00:09:52] Speaker B: And churches and systems can be organized around threat. They're systems just like nervous systems, right. Larger, you know, collective systems, institutional systems can be organized around a threat or suspicion or vigilance or competition. I tell the story in that book, if I can remember now of. Because I. All of my stories are an amalgamation of multiple stories. So that [00:10:17] Speaker A: I, [00:10:18] Speaker B: I'm not telling on someone, right. But of a, someone who ascended, a friend of mine who ascended into ministry leadership at a large Christian ministry where when he. When he took over the leadership of this ministry, what he quickly discovered was that their. What he had hoped was that there was this deep sense of like a kingdom ethic, humility, a real concern for and care for their people. What he discovered was that institutionally within, there were dynamics that were incredibly unhealthy. The senior leaders within there weren't trusted. But on a larger scale, there was this dynamic of competition with all the other ministries that were doing similar things. We're doing it better, and our. Our curriculum and our resources are the best. And. And he said, there's no sense of, like, we're participating in something that is bigger than us and we're, you know, there are other ministries that do similar things, but we get to do it alongside those ministries. There wasn't any sense of that. There was a sense that we are the best. And it. And for him, it became intolerable over three or four months and he had to step out. [00:11:35] Speaker A: But truly, that comes trickle down from the leader, right? [00:11:39] Speaker B: Yes. Yeah, yeah, yeah. You know, and oftentimes you can track it back to a founding leader or early leaders within the system. But it is interesting that the system itself takes on that dynamic. So much so that when I've done this work within larger systems, they'll say, well, let's just take the unhealthy leader out and we'll be fine. But it doesn't work that way. And someone else steps into the void. I can't tell you how many times I've done that kind of work in a larger, let's say larger church. And the narcissistic leader is taken out, and they're like, we're done with you, Chuck. We're not going to do any more consulting. And I'll say, but. But we're only getting started. We've got to do a lot more work. And then they call me back, six, eight, ten months later. Yeah. [00:12:22] Speaker A: Well, good, good. Do you think one more, like, big research question before we dive into your book? Because I feel like I'm seeing more books coming out. You know, I'm thinking of even, like, Scott McKnight and Adrian, who put out Traumatized church. [00:12:37] Speaker B: Yeah. [00:12:38] Speaker A: I feel like there are more books and yours that are helping churches to create health in those systems. And I'm wondering if it's because narcissism has changed over the past years. Like, have we seen it grow either in faith leaders or I would say, leaders who leverage faith. [00:12:57] Speaker B: Yeah. Your questions are so good. Yeah. And narcissism does evolve. It does. And I often say that, you know, if Genesis 3 is the origin of it, and we see this kind of narcissistic leadership, if you want to call it that, you know, it's a contemporary term, but in scripture, even, you know, even among some of the kings and some of the more brutal leaders of God's people, and even beyond that, then, yeah, does it does change over time? It does evolve over time in different contexts. One of the things that I'm talking about in the new book is how, you know, I was talking a lot about pastoral leaders and ministry leaders in the earlier book, but how we're seeing it evolved, evolve in and through social media in all kinds of ways, including among therapists and wellness experts. Mean my Instagram, I scroll through and I'm kind of stunned. There are some who I know who are brand new to, let's say, enneagram work, or nervous system work, or trauma informed work, and they pop that identifier on their, you know, on their bio, and they start talking like they're experts and they're putting out videos and they're really good at that kind of stuff. And I'm [00:14:10] Speaker A: like, [00:14:10] Speaker B: wow, this is. This is just the way it goes. Right. For the sake of, like, likes or platform building and without a core integrity. And that's, you know, that's what's happening sort of across the board. And ultimately the narcissism conversation gets back to. It's about health. Right. It's, of course, it's about family systems and stories and things like that, but ultimately it's about character and integrity. [00:14:39] Speaker A: Yeah. So your new book, you just mentioned who youo're Becoming. [00:14:42] Speaker B: Yeah. [00:14:43] Speaker A: The Slow and Courageous Work of Cultivating Character in a Narcissistic Age. I have it right here. [00:14:48] Speaker B: Yeah. [00:14:48] Speaker A: Is this a response to what you've seen, or are you, like, addressing now a new, different aspect of narcissism? [00:14:55] Speaker B: Yeah, I'd say a little bit of both. I think there is a bit of an evolution over the last six years based on what I've seen. It's also in response to questions that I've gotten over the last six years. One of the major questions being, can people really change, or how do people change? Or take us behind the scenes and help us to understand the dynamics? And that's a bit of what I get into. Particularly in the first chapter. I kind of jump right into, if we're going to do this work, if we're really going to see people change, we can't address it moralistically. We can't just throw more practices at people. We've got to recognize, as I was talking about earlier, and this is where your question was so good to come, kind of really get beneath the narcissism dynamic, right. We have to address a nervous system in survival mode. And so I can't simply give someone a list of things to do over a two month sabbatical and hope that they'll change. We've actually got to work with a body with a nervous system that has adapted over the course of maybe 15, 20, 30, 40 years, depending on the age of the person that I'm working with. And that's why it's a slow and courageous work. That's why it can't. As you know, there are quick comebacks these days and there have been for years. And so someone's back after a two month sabbatical or a year away and they've got a new ministry website, video series, platform, church, whatever it might be. [00:16:29] Speaker A: Along those lines, I know at the time of recording right now, Carl Lentz, who was the previous pastor of Hillsong Church, is doing, I don't know, some people are calling it like a restoration tour, but basically he's publicly announcing his return to ministry. And so I'm curious, regardless of your personal thoughts, you know, on Carl Lentz himself, does this represent a pattern or a behavior that you've seen as you've researched, like narcissism in leadership? [00:16:56] Speaker B: Yeah, yeah, I think it is a pattern. I think we're seeing it all over the place. You know, I don't know the behind the scenes specifics. I have people in one ear telling me he's done really good work. I've got people in my other year tell me otherwise. I don't know about the specifics. What I do know is that there seems to be this pattern of a quick turnaround, a book, you know, we, we experience transformation now we want to talk about transformation and we want to help others. And I do wish, regardless of the details of this particular story, that people would choose invisibility for a lot longer. Right. It, it seems that we need to emerge in some new way. And if it's good, you know, if it's transformational, if it's, if it's a story of what I learned in therapy even, right. It's justified in some way. And I've seen this happen too often and I've been behind the scenes in some of these cases too often where I know that they shouldn't have gotten the book contract. But publishers, this is not an indictment on all publishers, but there are some publishers that want that book contract. They [00:18:07] Speaker A: want the [00:18:07] Speaker B: turnaround story, [00:18:08] Speaker A: the [00:18:08] Speaker B: restoration story, and they know it's going to sell. People are going to buy books like that too. Right. So, yeah. [00:18:16] Speaker A: Do you think, I mean, I get the publishers, but I also just wonder, as you know, the body as church communities, as Christianity, whoever you want we to be in this question, do you think we kind of tend to muddle, you know, forgiveness, restoration, reconciliation, reinstatement, whatever it is, especially if the person that we're talking about is charismatic or gifted or valuable to an institution? [00:18:40] Speaker B: Yeah, yeah, yeah, certainly. I mean, I think in, in some of these cases, these are people who are, have had a reach that goes beyond their, their local church. Right. Like, you don't tend to see these things happen in the, in the rural church in quite the same way. Right. But if there's some sort of public ministry and broader reach. Right. I, I, in some ways it's like, as I've worked with folks like this, I can tell you from the inside, there's an addiction to being seen. There's an addiction to the platform. It's like the pastor that I talk about in the new book that I worked with, who, you know, I told him to choose invisibility, to step away from platform, from his church, and within just a couple of months, he had a podcast out. And I called him out on that, you know, and he was like, well, it's only a podcast, but we had to get at like, I can't not be seen. There's a line that I have in there that I'm, I'm kind of proud of. It's like, if I'm not shining, I might disappear. Disappear. And there's this sense that it, I, if I'm irrelevant, if I'm not, you know, if I'm not on camera, if I'm not on stage, there, there's a sense of emptiness that they're going to have to live with that they don't want to live with. And that's my job behind the scenes as I sit with them on that couch over there, to help them stay with that discomfort, that emptiness, that insecurity that you were naming earlier, that shame, and say, we, we can do this. Apart from the cameras, apart from the platform, apart from the stage, apart from the podcast, we. You can stay with discomfort and you're going to be okay. [00:20:20] Speaker A: But it's so hard, Chuck. Like, I, you said that quote, and I was like, ah, that Hurts my feelings a little bit because I can recognize, you know, I. Like I said, I'm a pastor. I preach, I speak. Speak. I have a podcast. [00:20:33] Speaker B: Yes. [00:20:34] Speaker A: I'm active on social media. You know, I know this about myself. I know that I've. I've got certain gifts and skills, and not only am I good at it, but I like it. [00:20:42] Speaker B: Yes. [00:20:44] Speaker A: And so I can take, like. I'm literally going to put that quote somewhere as a reminder to myself of, like, hey, don't be this person. But I also think this is one of the hardest things for us to recognize in ourselves. [00:20:55] Speaker B: Yeah. Yeah. [00:20:56] Speaker A: Because we tend to get defensive. Right. If somebody points it out. So I know, again, back to the book. Will you kind of give us. [00:21:02] Speaker B: Yeah. [00:21:03] Speaker A: How psychology and neurobiology can help us to not only reveal and, like, accept these things, but then rebuild. [00:21:10] Speaker B: Yeah. Well, you actually just named something that's really important, that defensiveness. Right. So. And which. Which we could connect to our bodies, to our nervous systems, to a primal resistance. Right. To anyone. Like, if someone comes to me and says, chuck, because like you, I have opportunities to do these kinds of things and write and. And get up and speak in different places. If someone comes to me and asks me a question about it, if there's an immediate resistance or defensiveness, that tells me something, that ought to tell the people who know me best something about what's going on inside of me. If there's a moment of curiosity and humility, if there's not that, by the way, as you talk about that sense of certainty, but more of a sense of humility. Say more about that. I want to hear. Maybe I do need to consider pausing, stepping away, going quiet for a while, then. Then that's a reflection of a deeper groundedness and a settled nervous system. And so these. These subtle things are indicators of nervous systems that are dysregulated, more reactive, or nervous systems that are more reflective of what Paul might call in Ephesians 3, a rooted and grounded person. Rooted and grounded in love. Right. And that's the work over the course of our years in ministry. None of us, by the way, do that perfectly. It's not an either or. And there are going to be times where it's like, I'm fine. I'm doing this. Great. Why are you asking that doesn't necessarily need to be reflective of poor character or something like that. But I would say that's where we need people in our lives, asking really good question questions like, I celebrate that you are a pastor and that you've had these opportunities. Part of the gift of teaching at the seminary is that there have been so many women that I've been able to come alongside. And oftentimes the women who come to seminary in their first year, they're like, oh, I'm not called to be a preacher. And then they're the very best preacher in the class. Right. And it's like, oh, yes, you are. But what about narcissism? I don't want to get. I don't want to be one of those people. That's a pretty good indicator that you're probably not a narcissist. Right. That reluctance. And I actually think that that's a good sign for many women they haven't been socialized into. You are God's gift to the church. Like, I was told when I was in fifth grade that I'd be a pastor by my first pastor. Right. So a lot of us as men were socialized. A lot of women grew up with, no, you'll never have that opportunity. Right. And so there's something [00:23:40] Speaker A: that we shouldn't, but, like, prideful. It's. I think that we should be in front of people or whatever. I know, at least for. For me, that was the tension of, like, [00:23:49] Speaker B: yeah, [00:23:49] Speaker A: maybe I am called to do this, but, [00:23:51] Speaker B: yeah, isn't that interesting? On the one hand, you're entitled to it, particularly me as a white male. Right. And on the other hand, that's prideful. Right. And so there is something about that that we need to pay attention to. And so, you know, when you connect the body, the neurobiology conversation, things like that, what we're looking for is something that's happening not just at a behavioral level, but at a neurobiological level, at a somatic level. Like, what's happening in your body? When I. When I go into consult for churches, if I work with a pastor who's highly defended, that tells me a lot about what. What his body has, how his body has lived for a good number of years. Right. Tells me something probably about his story. And I'd say 99 out of 100 times, when I have the opportunity to get in and dig in a little deeper, that's what I find, is that this didn't start yesterday. This started a long time ago. Right. And so we've got significant work to do, and he will likely need to step away for some time to do that work. Yeah. [00:24:54] Speaker A: Chuck, how often do you think that we fool ourselves where the person we're becoming is different from the person that we think we Are. [00:25:01] Speaker B: Yes. You know, I don't know about how often I do. I do sense that it's. It's particularly endemic, if I could put it that way, to Christian ministry. We. There's this word in psychology, ego, syntonic. It's where the mask becomes the only face. You know, it's like, this is. This is who I am. And that's what I hear from people. I'm. I'm not narcissistic. I'm just a three. An enneagram three, you know. Right. Or [00:25:33] Speaker A: hurting my feelings. Chuck. [00:25:34] Speaker B: Oh, yeah. And, well, you know, you could. I could walk through every enneagram type. I'm. I'm a one. I'm just. I'm just lawyerly. I'm just right all the time. Right. You can just go through every number and, and see it show up in one way or another. And so, yeah, we do fool ourselves, particularly when we surround ourselves. Like, I. I've gone into churches where, you know, the leader has been surrounded. A male or a female leader has been surrounded by people who say all the nicest things. You know, do you have people in your life? Do people in your life have permission to say hard things? You know, I. I happen to teach at a seminary here with a really great leader. And he's not perfect. There are things that he does that I disagree with. But he will sit in my office here and he'll open up his journal and he'll let me speak to him for an hour about things that I'm seeing or wondering about. He'll allow me to ask hard questions. And I value that. That's really rare in leaders. And that takes a certain kind of security. And this is where your initial observation about insecurity is so significant. It takes a certain kind of security for Felix, the president of our seminary, to sit here and say, tell me more, tell me more. I want to hear a little bit more about what you're saying versus no, that's not true about me. It's very, very different. [00:27:01] Speaker A: Right. I mean, it takes a lot of self awareness to be able to even get to this place. [00:27:05] Speaker B: Right. [00:27:07] Speaker A: So let me ask you. And I know, I love. Actually, before I ask you that, I love that in the book, it really is a guide. Like, you've got practices in here for people where you, you've got blanks, you've got prompts, you've got. I mean, actual, like. [00:27:21] Speaker B: I [00:27:21] Speaker A: wanted it to be a workbook. Reflection, [00:27:23] Speaker B: in a way. Yeah. I wanted it to be a workbook in a sense. [00:27:27] Speaker A: It really is. [00:27:28] Speaker B: Yeah. [00:27:29] Speaker A: Yeah. And I think that it's going to help people, you know, across the board. But again, we have to. People have to be willing to have the conversation. Right, [00:27:36] Speaker B: Right. Yeah. [00:27:38] Speaker A: So if someone's listening and they, whether it's a pastor, a spouse, whoever, if there's someone in their life and they're like, I think I'm dealing with someone who has narcissistic personality, but they're not to the self awareness place yet. [00:27:51] Speaker B: Yes. [00:27:52] Speaker A: What do they do? [00:27:53] Speaker B: Oh, that's such a tough question [00:27:56] Speaker A: because [00:27:57] Speaker B: the. What do they [00:27:57] Speaker A: do? You are the expert. [00:27:59] Speaker B: Yeah. You know, that's, that's a tricky one because it looks different in different situations. What I can say, generally speaking is we begin first with safety. What do you do? You find your way to some, some safety, safe person, a safe therapist, a safe pastor like you, someone who will hold space and hold their story with care, with kindness. Because I there. What you need to realize is that this has had an impact on you. And you may be living in a dysregulated place in your own way, you may be prone to be reactive to take on that narcissistic husband, for instance. Right. And oftentimes that doesn't work well at all. And so I'd want you to find your way to someone who's safe and kind and generous and who can hold space for you to shift from that dysregulated place to a more grounded place, yourself. And then discern together what's next? What do I need to do? Because the what's next is at times we, we need to change the locks on your house. We need to get you to a safe place. We need to get your children to a safe place. You know, we need to call children Family services. I mean, there are, there are immediate crisis level things that are appropriate in some situations. In other situations it's like, okay, we need to explore whether or not he's willing to get into counseling and sit with you and explore some of these dynamics. And if that's the case, that might be a wise next step. So it really varies situation by situation, but I really want the person who's experiencing the harm to be cared for. Well and to experience some sense of safety. [00:29:46] Speaker A: Yeah, [00:29:46] Speaker B: yeah. [00:29:48] Speaker A: Well, when we're talking about, you know, other people and restoration and again, even a little bit with like, you know, re. Platforming. Do you think that, that. Because we're talking about, right. Like, you know, therapy and one on one coaching and that kind of thing. But surely restoration is not just reserved for that person. But does it would need to include, I would think, also the people that were hurt in the process. [00:30:11] Speaker B: Yes, exactly. And that's what's often missed, right. In these kinds of processes. Like, is there a process that really centers the, the experience, the harm of the survivor in it? Right. Because oftentimes the sort of gravity, gravitational energy goes to the person who's done the harm. And it always does. He's the biggest personality in the room. Right. And, and so we swoop in with a plan for him to take a two month sabbatical and to do all the things. And then he comes back remorseful and it's, I have questions about whether or not that's genuine remorse. But he comes back and the survivors are expected to just say, oh, well, thank you for going on your sabbatical, by the way. I didn't get a sabbatical. And and now I'm, I'm expected to sort of say, I forgive you and everything's good now and welcome back and I'm glad you had a good two months off. And that's not the way it's supposed to work. Right. And so now how we do that differs, again, as we were talking about last time, you know, it's last question. It differs from person to person, situation to situation. But I really, I want to ask. Judith Herman has a. She's been writing for decades now, if you're familiar with her work on trauma and abuse. And she's got a new book out on victims and survivors of abuse. And she says, what is a survivor? She asked, what does a survivor need? Let's shift the conversation to prioritize the needs of the person who's been harmed. What would be helpful to you? What do you need? How can we care for you? What would reparation, restitution look like, repair look like? If you're not ready, that's okay. You're not demanded to forgive. Right. [00:31:57] Speaker A: I'm so glad you said that. I'm so glad you said that because that's one of those things that I feel like people too, right. It's like you're. Everybody's on a timeline. So it's like if the person that caused harm comes back and they're ready, then you definitely also need to be ready. It's like, well, hold on, [00:32:10] Speaker B: right? [00:32:10] Speaker A: I might not be ready for a long time. [00:32:13] Speaker B: Long time. [00:32:14] Speaker A: And there's not a timeline. [00:32:16] Speaker B: Yeah, yeah, there's not a timeline. And so this is where Judith Herman is talking about, you know, prioritizing the needs, the process of the person who has survived the harm and that process. You know, there are times when I've worked with people who do want to sit with a person who's done the harm and have a face to face conversation and engage. I, I know others who are like, no, I'm, I'm actually, I need to be done and completely done and everything in between. Right. And so how do we honor that and honor their process and get them the care that they need? If the church is willing to spend thousands of dollars, for instance, to send people to folks like me to do some, get some care. Right. I do these five day counseling intensives for people who've done the harm, but also for people who are victims of harm. Right. But if they're willing to send someone to me to get that kind of care, to give them a two month sabbatical or whatever it might be, what do we need to do? And how, how might we prioritize those who have been harmed, other staff members, for instance, who were fired over the course of the years before? If it's a pastor, other people within the orbit of the, you know, the husband who done the abusive, the abusing within the relationship, the kids, other family members, whatever the case may be. [00:33:35] Speaker A: Yeah. Okay. Chuck, I have a really big question that I did not prep you for. [00:33:41] Speaker B: That's okay. [00:33:41] Speaker A: But as we're talking about this, I'm just thinking, you know, I live very much in the like, deconstruction, reconstruction world. A lot of the people that they call me their Instagram pastor, like, it started as a joke, but I'm like, oh, no, this is actually where I'm doing a good portion of my ministry. [00:33:59] Speaker B: Wow. Yeah. [00:34:01] Speaker A: Because I have a lot of people that will send me a message and say I've experienced, you know, whether it's narcissism, church hurt, trauma, whatever, spiritual trauma, to the point that not only could they not like find restoration with the, that person, maybe they've moved, maybe that person's gone, but they're having a hard time even getting back into the institution of church. And I always tell them, you know, there's not a timeline. This is not a bait and switch where I'm trying to like rush you back in. [00:34:26] Speaker B: Yes. [00:34:27] Speaker A: But also my heart is for people to eventually be able to get to that place. For the people that are listening and they are listening to this podcast that are in that space, what would you want them to know? [00:34:39] Speaker B: Yeah, well, I'm with you 100% on this. Right. There isn't a timeline. So we want you to take that process Slowly. And church community can look different in different times. I mean, when we look at the history of the church, people have gathered in different ways over the course of many, many centuries. Right. And so I was. I was working with someone just recently who tried again to go to church. And as soon as she stepped into the foyer, it was a. It was simply the act of stepping into a foyer. I think that's what they're called in some churches, whatever they're called. You know, that kind of entry space before you go into the main worship area. Right. This was a completely different church in a different city. And it was like her heart started beating. You know, she became dysregulated, and she went into, if people understand a bit about the nervous system, kind of a freeze state, [00:35:34] Speaker A: you [00:35:34] Speaker B: know, deer in headlight state, where she. She described as kind of numb and catatonic, and she was just going through the motions, and she couldn't even really remember. She knows she was shaking hands with people. Her husband told her that she had some polite conversation with folks. She stayed, and she sort of came to a couple of days later with her therapist, and it was like, I'm not ready yet, you know, until I can go in. And maybe it's putting a foot in, you know, maybe it's going to church on a weekday and simply standing outside or here again, different bodies inhabit these realities in different ways. And so how do we honor the different bodies and how trauma lands in each individual body? This is the case across the board. I think of women's experiences. I think of the experiences of people of color who've experienced not only spiritual abuse, but racial microaggressions. Trauma lands differently in different bodies. What do you need? [00:36:42] Speaker A: Yeah, I'm so glad you said that. Okay, so here's my next big question for you. [00:36:48] Speaker B: Yeah. [00:36:49] Speaker A: I feel like right now we've got. I will talk about right now, in America and Christianity specifically, we have a lot of leaders that are, I would say, leveraging faith for power, for control, for manipulation, whatever. Fill in the blank, whatever you want to call it. And unfortunately, to me, it appears as though people are then taking that model, and we are seeing more and more narcissistic leadership that is harmful. But, Chuck, it's not even, like, secretive anymore. It's like we're saying the quiet things out loud. Are you following me? [00:37:28] Speaker B: Yeah. [00:37:29] Speaker A: And people are going, great, yeah, let's do this. And when we hold this up to Jesus, or we hold this up to what Christian leadership should look like, whether that's in the church or any kind of leader, again, leveraging faith or the words of Jesus. [00:37:46] Speaker B: Yeah. [00:37:48] Speaker A: What do you think people, like, why are people following this? I guess is my big question. What are we missing or what are we afraid of that we're going like, no, this is a great model to follow. [00:38:02] Speaker B: Yeah. Yeah. Gosh, you ask good questions and hard questions. Right. Because I think in, in many ways we've been discipled into this, this kind of American Christianity that worships power, wealth, influence, image, all of all of these kinds of things. Right. And so we've been socialized. We've been discipled into this over the course of, of decades, really. Right. I was thinking, I was thinking recently about, for me, I was born in 1970, and so I just growing up through the 70s. And I remember in 1976. And so this dates me, obviously asking my dad, who's going to vote for. Is Jimmy Carter versus, versus who was it? Gerald Ford, I guess. And, and they were voting for the Democrat. There were Christians voting for the Democrat. Right. And. And it's always interesting to me, you know, nowadays that's, I mean, that would be so foreign to some people. Right. But [00:38:58] Speaker A: yeah, [00:38:58] Speaker B: it's, it's fascinating. But we've been socialized into this way of understanding spirituality, faith, allegiance, that I think is a departure from the ways of Jesus. The Beatitudes, the Sermon on the Mount, the Fruits of the Spirit, Philippians 2, the Christ hymn, the Humble Way of Jesus, the early expressions. There's this wonderful book by a historian named Alan Kreider called the Patient Ferment of the Early Church, where he talks about early expressions of faith, the humility and generosity of early Christians, even in the midst of social issues. Our faith has really been shaped, it goes back, it goes back many centuries by a kind of Constantinian, Christendom, Constantine, the emperor that became a Christian, where Christians ascended into power and conflated faith with power and influence, political power and influence. Right. Social power and influence. And so there's a preservation of that. And I think what's interesting about it, there's a CIA profiler named Gerald Post who did work around narcissism and narcissistic leaders, from Bill Clinton to Donald Trump, in fact. And he, Gerald Post said there's this interesting dynamic where there's the mirror hungry leader. It's that narcissistic leader who needs you to be the mirror. And so he loves getting up in front of an audience because that fuels him. And the ideal hungry follower, and the ideal hungry follower follows the narcissistic leader. Because there are certain ideals, certain even deep needs and values that are met, that might be. And this is what's important to listen for, a need for security. This is the leader who is going to make our nation secure, is going to protect us from all the bad people out there. Right. And so there's this psychological dynamic between powerful leader and devoted follower that is that, that is hard to break, frankly. And for those of us who are pastors and leaders to talk about the way of Jesus and the Beatitudes, it sort of goes in one ear and out the other because their entire imagination has been formed around socially, psychologically, around this particular way of following this particular form of security that they've been promised. Right. And, and, and God and protecting Christian faith has been connected to it. Right. So all the better. We can vote for that. We can follow that. We can elevate that kind of leader in our church. Right. So it's, it's, it's going to be. I think it's a tough challenge for you as a pastor, as a leader, as an someone of influence. Right. To invite people to the way of Jesus, to an alternative kind of imagination. Right. Of what it means to follow Jesus in a world where people have been socialized into this way of being. That, to me, is a counterfeit version of Christianity. Yeah. [00:42:11] Speaker A: Okay, I have to break in real quick because I can't let Chuck talk about a counterfeit version of Christ Christianity without letting you know that there is more to it than what one society or the norms of your denomination may have told you. There is a faith where imagination and curiosity and wonder won't take you farther away from God, but will help you learn to follow Jesus with your eyes on him more than on the guidelines that are laid out for you for what it means to be a good Christian. If this is a foreign concept to you or it sounds like the new way forward that you need, I would love to help you begin to redirect your need for safety, security, control, or even a promised good life toward a confidence in the overwhelming love of God that will transform you without shame. That's what I hope you'll find in my first book that is out now, the Other side of Certainty. You can pick up a copy from Amazon or your favorite local bookstore through bookshop.org both of which are linked in the show notes. I love it. And I love that you use the word imagination twice, because to me, that's what's lacking. I think in this blind allegiance there is a lack of imagination. There's a Lack of curiosity. There is a lack of critical thinking, honestly, where it's just. So I guess what I think I hear you saying we would need to encourage listeners to do is to really sit in that self awareness and self reflection and go, what am I? Yeah, what am I? What am I trying to get from this person. [00:43:44] Speaker B: Yes. [00:43:45] Speaker A: Instead of from God, [00:43:46] Speaker B: you know, So I think you're putting your finger on it in a way that gets it our earlier conversation, and that's that they're not merely going to change their minds because you post something on Facebook that reflects a different way of thinking. Right. Because there's a psychological dynamic because their nervous systems are wrapped around a particular way of. Of maintaining security in the world. Right. And so if your body is in dysregulation and in a form of survival mode, and it feels like I may not like everything about this pastor, this CEO, this political leader, there are things he's a little rough around the edges, but, you know, he does what's right for me, that's wrapped up in a psyche and a collective psyche even of like, we're in danger. And notice that's oftentimes that that's the narrative. We're in danger. And you will be. Life will be more dangerous under this particular leader. Right. So that only fuels dysregulation. And so this is why I think a kind of contemplative spirituality, a grounded spirituality, grounded pastors and leaders like you are so very important. Can we, you know, I'm a therapist. I get to create that space here. And it takes a while for people to shift, you know, into that more grounded place. But can. You know, I think this is actually exciting. This is one of the really exciting things about pastoring nowadays is how do we. How do we. How do we think about what we do throughout the week? How do we think about worship that creates that kind of space for people to find their way back to grounding, back to safety, back to a place of real anchoring in Jesus. And that's, you know, I think that's kind of rare. [00:45:37] Speaker A: Yeah. Well, I think more than anything, Livin Abraham is a pastor in Texas, and he and I just had this conversation specifically about, you know, the midterms and how we really have to help teach our people to think. Like, I think for a long time, church was just, you know, one person stood behind the pulpit, said some things. The congregation took it in and said, okay, because you said it, I'll believe it. [00:45:59] Speaker B: And [00:45:59] Speaker A: where we are now, it's like, no, as pastors, we we have to choose actively not to do that. [00:46:05] Speaker B: Yeah. [00:46:05] Speaker A: And instead to help people think about. No, don't. Just. I know you left one thing. Don't. Now, just take what I'm saying. Because I'm saying it. Think about it. Like, [00:46:14] Speaker B: how [00:46:14] Speaker A: does this sit with you? Wrestle with this. Take it to the scriptures. Ask Holy Spirit, you know. [00:46:18] Speaker B: Yes. For [00:46:19] Speaker A: discernment and helping our people to own. [00:46:21] Speaker B: Yeah. [00:46:22] Speaker A: Their faith, their beliefs. [00:46:23] Speaker B: Yeah, yeah. Like, you're. This is why you asked me, would you ever want to go back into pastoring or some version of that? No. [00:46:30] Speaker A: Yeah. [00:46:31] Speaker B: Because look what you have to deal with. You know, I'm. I get to be behind the scenes. Like, I'm. I'm that retired, you know, athlete that's up in the booth now. You know, comment commenting on games. You know, you're in it, and you're having to think about this all the time. Right. And it. And it feels different than, like, when I was in seminary in the 90s, the worship wars were the big thing. You know, this is so much more difficult. And so, you know, to disciple people into a new imagination, to a new way of being in the world, so that when they hear the Beatitudes, they're. They're like, oh, that actually resonates versus, like, that's just woke, you know, something very different. Right. It's so challenging. [00:47:14] Speaker A: Yeah. Well, I was going to ask you, Chuck, like, how do people cultivate their character? And you've said multiple times, you know, going back to the Beatitudes and the fruits of the Spirit. So I don't know if it's that, if you want to elaborate on it. [00:47:28] Speaker B: Yeah, yeah. I mean, I think I get into the. This process that invites us to slow way down, obviously. Right. That's right there in the subtitle. And. And to pay attention to what's happening at a. At a fundamental level, even at the level of our bodies. Right. This is where the neurobiology of it all is so important. Important. And not that I think that, you know, that's exactly what Jesus or the Apostle Paul or others were talking about across the New Testament. But I do think that there is this sense of the settled place, this grounded place. It's fascinating to me that the Beatitudes begin with blessed are the patokos in the Greek, those who've come to the very end of themselves, not the ones who prop themselves up by their, you know, pull themselves up by their bootstraps. But it's like where AA starts with powerlessness, with brokenness, follows with mourning, and Then meekness and hunger and thirst, right? This isn't a spirituality that's put together, that's certain, by the way. Hint, hint at someone's book, right? This is, this is a spirituality of humility, of surrender, of powerlessness. And, and you know, that's, I think, where it begins. And so we find our way to that place. And I can tell you that when I'm working with people on the narcissistic spectrum, that feels very uncomfortable. And I understand that because, you know, we've, we've. And think about this collectively too, within institutions, within political systems, like, there's a profound fear of powerlessness. Like, I don't want to be in that place of humiliation. I don't want to. And I think honestly, those of us in like the spiritual abuse space have been talking about this for a number of years. After my book came out in 2000, there were some other books, Diane Langberg, Scott McKnight, others. We saw a doubling down in the church and politically and nationally. Right. We saw a, we saw a lot of people like me, I can now say I'm a late middle aged white man, you know, who were really scared of losing influence, really threatened by some of the things that were coming out. I mean, I had a lot of men asking me, are they coming after me? Are they after all white men? You know, and so there was an, there was, there was a collective like fear, powerlessness, and people operating out of that place in a way that they double down. Let's, you know, let's reclaim power for ourselves. And that's. That to me is really scary. But I think the way through is the way of powerlessness. I think the way through is the way of humility. It's the way of, I don't know if you'd call it from your perspective, uncertainty, because that can sound a little bit weird to people. But I know Leslie Newbegin in his book Proper Confidence, talked about the difference between certainty and confidence. You know, it's a refreshing, humble confidence. Right? That and no, we're not against all white men. I'm not against all white men. But that's the myth that's created, right, to perpetuate this dysregulation that leads to propping up powerful, harmful leaders. [00:50:44] Speaker A: Yeah. Well, anytime we can point a finger at a group, right? Anytime it's like, well, if this group is not the scapegoat anymore, then it's got to be this group or it's got to be this group because it makes us feel better. Point to someone Else. Because then it's not us. [00:50:55] Speaker B: Yeah, [00:50:56] Speaker A: so. [00:50:56] Speaker B: Yeah, that's right. Let me just tell all the men out there we're going to be okay. You know, like Jesus. As Leslie Newbiggin said, Jesus is still Lord. We're going to be okay. Right? [00:51:05] Speaker A: Pretty sure y' all are going to be fine. [00:51:07] Speaker B: We're going to be fine. Take a [00:51:09] Speaker A: deep breath. Yes, Deep breath. Deep breath. Regulate that nervous system. [00:51:13] Speaker B: Yeah. [00:51:14] Speaker A: Last question for you, which is the last question I ask everyone on the show, because the podcast is called Becoming Church. How can the people listening become the church to the people around them? [00:51:23] Speaker B: Immediately, when you said that, the word that came to mind was need. And I think the reason that came to mind is it's a. You know, I think the church is a. Is not a social club. You know, primarily, it's. It is a place where we can come with our needs, where we can come with our pain, where we can come with our fears, with our insecurity. Right. And. And so. And so often people come to me now, you know, with my therapist hat on, and say, boy, I experience more care in an AA meeting on a Wednesday night at my church than on a Sunday morning. And so I just wonder how our communities become gracious places, generous spaces where people experience real care, real love. They really feel seen. You know, that's different. That would be different. Maybe that's not as sexy. Maybe you don't grow big, big churches like that. But I think that there's something about that. When I think about Alan Kreider's work, that book I mentioned earlier, the Patient for Men of the early church, it was a church in profound need. The Roman empires weren't particularly kind to this budding Christian movement. Right. And so a church in persecution is often a church that's really dependent on Jesus. Right. And really dependent on one another. And I happen to think that if it all goes south, you know, and the empire crumbles, we'll be okay, because Jesus is still Jesus, and we might actually find our way to a place of more care, more need, more generosity toward one another. [00:53:03] Speaker A: That dependence may actually put us in the place where Jesus wants us to be operating from to begin with. [00:53:09] Speaker B: Yeah, that's well said. [00:53:11] Speaker A: Oh, thank you. Chuck has been so great. I'm really grateful for your voice and your work, and so thank you for all that you're doing to just bring health back into the body of Christ. [00:53:22] Speaker B: Yeah, thank you, too, for all the work that you're doing for your book, for your writing, for your ministry, too, [00:53:29] Speaker A: Chuck. Is so kind to keep nodding toward my book, the Other side of Certainty. And yes, I would love for you to read it after you take this conversation one step further by reading who you're becoming by Chuck DeGroat. It's all linked up in the show Notes for easy access, along with over 160 Other books by authors who have also been on this show. If there's someone in your life that you want to have these conversations with, but they're not quite there yet, a bundle of books, some fun pens for taking notes, and a cozy blanket would make a really good holiday gift for all of the holidays we have coming up. There's plenty of topics for you to choose from on our resource lists. Until next time, thanks so much for being here and keep becoming the church of the people around you.

Other Episodes

Episode 145

December 21, 2025 • 01:00:19
Episode Cover

Mattie Jo Cowsert: Life After Purity Culture

What happens when an Evangelical Pastor’s daughter (who raised in purity culture) moves to NYC to deconstruct her beliefs on sex? She also ends...

Listen

Episode 102

February 23, 2025 • 00:45:35
Episode Cover

Brenna Blain: Can I Say That in Church?

Brenna Blain, a contemporary theologian, brings the current problems and issues of the world together with scripture to help people understand how to interact...

Listen

Episode 190

November 01, 2026 • 00:47:58
Episode Cover

When Politics Becomes our Religion with Libin Abraham

Following Jesus in a politically polarized world is contentious enough. When faith language is added to campaigns and Christianity is uplifted like a mascot,...

Listen